Briony Costanza.
Thesis-V for vendetta has a variety of
themes and messages. It is a dystopian film as throughout it presents warnings
and messages. The film shows a fascist government who manipulate the country
with “fear and panic”. The film was released after the terror attacks, which
occurred in London and America (9/11), it created conspiracies of whether these
attacks had any connection to the government as in V for Vendetta the
government, are actually the terrorists. The film made the audience question
whether they could trust their government. V for Vendetta presents the
importance of freedom, and suggests the message that it is more important than
life. The film not only gives warnings of the future but also comparisons of
the past and present world, examples of this is Nazi Germany and how Hitler’s
power allowed the country to become a fascist dictatorship. The film also is
similar to the events in Guantanamo bay and the unjust acts that are occurring
to the people imprisoned there.
Main body-
Theme-Manipulation
Scene-Scene 1 (Voice of London), and the
scene of V preaching on the emergency channel
Analysis-The closeup of Lewis Prothero at
the beginning shows his importance, this also suggests that the public and
therefore believe and value his statements.
Synthesis- Should we believe everything we
are told by the media?
Theme-Fear
Scene-Eveys time in prison “People should
not fear their governments, the government should fear its people”
Analysis-The fear in the film is shown by
the obedience of the citizens. They are taught to think that they should be
obedient to the government and not to question them, as if they do they are
likely to be punished. The fingermen (secret police).
Synthesis-Have we been taught to work for
the upper class? Are we still living in a country with the ‘social ladder’ and
is it followed?
Theme-Identity
Scene-V cooking for Evey, The crowd of
people in V masks
Analysis-No one has their own identity in
the film. Gordon and Valerie are examples of peoples sexuality having to be
hidden or taken away. Eveys femininity is taken away by the mock prison camp
and we do not know the identity of V as he has no recollection of his life
before the detention centre. The mask creates a neutral gender for everyone so
they hide theirs and V’s. By wearing the masks they also conforming to the
governments want of not allowing people to be different.
Synthesis-Do we conform to the societies
‘norm’?
Theme-Terrorism
Scene-V blowing up the cathedral, the
revealing of the governments virus plan
Analysis- Comparison to Guy Fawkes,
Rokewood was mentioned and during the gun powder trial he was of said to “love
Catesby above any wordly man” suggesting he could’ve been gay and fighting for
his freedom. The government killing its own people, unable to trust anyone.
Synthesis-Can we trust our own government?
Makes us question 9/11 and London bombings?
Theme-Revolution
Scene-Crowd of V masks
Analysis-Shows that everyone together can
make a difference. A symbol of everyone united.
Synthesis-By being united we can make a
stand and get freedom. Revenge or silent protest?
Conclusion- The film shows different themes
to put across a message that freedom is more important than life, this is true
as without our freedom including speech and actions, we are unable to live with
our own lives as we choose.
Very good effort. Good analysis and linking of theme to idea/message. Consider how you can bring in closer textual aspects (ie Evey turns off the voice of London, Prothero recites his own propaganda - what does this say?).
ReplyDeleteTo improve:
Consider the role of V as both a terrorist or a instrument of vengence - what message do you get from this character, is it condoning the use of torture? Isn't Britain stronger and united under this government or are the rights of the individual more important? Consider these messages when you write about social norms and ideas in your conclusion.
Why is the film distopian and why do we need warning?
B